Evidence review

Side-profile convexity, Ricketts E-line and chin projection: what orthognathic panels show

Published layperson vs clinician tolerances for chin retrusion and protrusion, Ricketts' aesthetic plane across populations and why profile balance depends on nose and lip projection together.

Published
Last reviewed
Version
1.0
Reading time
9 min
Author
LooksMeter Research

Key findings

  1. 01Ricketts' aesthetic plane (E-line, drawn from nasal tip to soft-tissue pogonion) evaluates lip posture relative to nose and chin together, meaning a short nose or recessed chin makes normal lips cross the line.1, 2
  2. 02Controlled silhouette and profile experiments show that nose projection, lip fullness and chin prominence must be judged as a coupled triad: fuller lips require stronger chin support to maintain profile balance.2
  3. 03Orthognathic threshold panels show that small sagittal chin deviations of 2 to 4 mm remain within normal layperson acceptance, whereas retrusion or protrusion past roughly 6 mm triggers sharp drops in perceived attractiveness.3, 4
  4. 04Clinicians detect smaller sagittal discrepancies than lay observers, so self-measuring single-millimetre departures from textbook cephalometric means overstates real-world social impact.3

Section 1

The claims

Frontal portraits hide sagittal depth: how far forward the nasal tip, upper and lower lips and soft-tissue chin sit relative to the brow and subnasale. Social media posts often quote one rigid Ricketts E-line target (-4 mm upper lip, -2 mm lower lip) or claim that any visible profile convexity indicates a recessed jaw. Published orthodontic and maxillofacial perception studies test how human panels actually judge profile balance.1, 2, 3

Table 1Peer-reviewed evidence on side-profile planes and sagittal chin tolerances.
ClaimWhat the studies reportEvidence
One fixed lip-to-E-line millimetre target fits every nose length and ancestry groupNot supported. Because the E-line anchors on pronasale and pogonion, nasal projection and natural lip thickness shift normal E-line distances substantially across populations and sexes.1, 2Not supported
Moderate chin retrusion or protrusion within ~2-4 mm rarely triggers layperson penalties, while larger shifts (>6 mm) lower ratings sharplySupported across Incremental sagittal manipulation studies comparing orthognathic patients, clinicians and laypersons.3, 4Consistent
Lower-lip-to-chin transition angle shapes perceived chin prominence alongside raw horizontal projectionSupported. Sublabial fold depth and the lower-lip-chin prominence angle govern whether a chin reads balanced or weak in lateral view.5, 6Consistent

Consistent: several independent studies point the same way. Mixed: studies point in different directions. Limited: one or two studies, not yet repeated. Not supported: tested, with no effect found or one too small to matter.

Section 2

Ricketts' aesthetic plane and nose-lip-chin coupling

Ricketts (1968) defined the aesthetic plane as a straight reference line connecting the tip of the nose (pronasale) to the frontmost point of the soft-tissue chin (pogonion), reporting that in balanced European adult profiles the upper lip typically sat about 4 mm behind that plane and the lower lip about 2 mm behind it.1 Crucially, Ricketts also documented that children and adolescents sit closer to or slightly ahead of the plane because nasal cartilage and mandibular symphysis continue growing forward into early adulthood.

Czarnecki, Nanda and Currier (1993) varied nose size, lip protrusion and chin prominence systematically in androgynous profile silhouettes rated by dental professionals.2 Profile ratings depended on the three structures together rather than any single landmark in isolation: more prominent lips remained attractive when paired with commensurate chin and nasal projection, whereas a retrusive chin produced the steepest penalty across profile combinations, especially in male silhouettes.

Section 3

Quantitative tolerances for chin and mandibular prominence

Naini and colleagues (2012) altered sagittal chin prominence and overall mandibular prominence in controlled 2-mm increments from -12 mm retrusion to +12 mm protrusion and compared ratings from orthognathic patients, clinicians and laypeople.3, 4

Table 2Sagittal chin/mandibular deviation zones reported in Naini et al. (2012).
Sagittal shift from baselineLayperson & clinician responsePractical interpretation
0 to ±4 mmHigh acceptance across laypeople - indistinguishable from ideal up to ~2-3 mmNormal anatomical variation corridor
±4 to ±6 mmTransitional zone where clinicians flag imbalance sooner than lay observersNoticeable soft-profile character without extreme rating drop
Beyond -6 mm (retrusion) or +6 mm (protrusion)Consistent drop in rated attractiveness and rising surgical desire across all three groupsMarked sagittal discrepancy

Section 4

The lower-lip-chin angle and lower-third contour

Horizontal chin position relative to a vertical plumb line does not tell the whole story. Naini, Garagiola and Wertheim (2019) analysed the lower-lip-chin prominence angle and showed that excessive lower-lip procumbency or a deep mentolabial fold can make an anatomically normal chin appear retruded or make a modest chin read prominent.5 Saponaro et al. (2018) and Chen et al. (2022) likewise report that clean lower-third taper and defined chin-neck separation elevate layperson ratings of attractiveness and poise.6, 7

Section 5

Reading a side-profile photo accurately

  • True 90-degree yaw: Even 10 to 15 degrees of oblique turn toward or away from the lens hides or exaggerates nasal bridge and chin projection. Keep the far eyebrow completely hidden behind the bridge.
  • Natural head posture (Frankfort horizontal): Tilting the chin upward rotates pogonion forward and artificially opens the cervicomental angle, while looking down tucks the chin into submental soft tissue.
  • Relaxed lip seal and centric occlusion: Straining the mentalis muscle to close parted lips flattens the soft-tissue chin pad and dimples the skin.

Section 6

Limits of this review

Silhouette and altered-photograph studies hold hair, beard framing and three-dimensional cheek contours constant so sagittal shifts can be isolated experimentally. Soft-tissue photography also cannot separate dentoalveolar lip posture from skeletal jaw position, which requires clinical cephalometry.

References

  1. 1Ricketts RM. Esthetics, environment, and the law of lip relation. American Journal of Orthodontics. 1968;54(4):272-289. doi:10.1016/S0002-9416(68)90278-9 · PubMed
  2. 2Czarnecki ST, Nanda RS, Currier GF. Perceptions of a balanced facial profile. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics. 1993;104(2):180-187. doi:10.1016/S0889-5406(05)81008-X · PubMed
  3. 3Naini FB, Donaldson ANA, McDonald F, Cobourne MT. Assessing the influence of chin prominence on perceived attractiveness in the orthognathic patient, clinician and layperson. International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery. 2012;41(7):839-846. doi:10.1016/j.ijom.2012.01.012 · PubMed
  4. 4Naini FB, Donaldson ANA, Cobourne MT, McDonald F. Assessing the influence of mandibular prominence on perceived attractiveness in the orthognathic patient, clinician, and layperson. European Journal of Orthodontics. 2012;34(6):738-746. doi:10.1093/ejo/cjr098 · PubMed
  5. 5Naini FB, Garagiola U, Wertheim D. Analysing chin prominence in relation to the lower lip: The lower lip-chin prominence angle. Journal of Cranio-Maxillofacial Surgery. 2019;47(8):1310-1316. doi:10.1016/j.jcms.2019.06.002 · PubMed
  6. 6Saponaro G, Gasparini G, Boniello R, Pelo S, Doneddu P, Todaro M, et al.. The rules of attractiveness: A study on the lower facial third. Journal of Craniofacial Surgery. 2018;29(7):1945-1946. doi:10.1097/SCS.0000000000005051 · PubMed
  7. 7Chen J, Abousy M, Chow A, Girard A, Jenny H, Choi JW, et al.. Surgical versus nonsurgical lower face contouring: Layperson perceptions of attractiveness and personality traits. Journal of Craniofacial Surgery. 2022;33(2):552-556. doi:10.1097/SCS.0000000000008187 · PubMed

Every reference was checked against Crossref before publication. Those indexed in PubMed were checked there as well. Findings are summarised in our own words. Read the original before relying on a number.

How to cite

LooksMeter Research. Side-profile convexity, Ricketts E-line and chin projection: what orthognathic panels show. Version 1.0. 19 November 2026. https://www.looksmeter.com/research/side-profile-and-e-line-evidence

About this document

LooksMeter is a consumer appearance analysis product. This document is written by the LooksMeter team for general information. It has not been peer reviewed or reviewed by a medical professional. The measurements it describes are not clinically validated and are not a diagnosis or a medical device. See a qualified clinician about any health or surgical decision.

Corrections are welcome at [email protected]. Material changes are recorded by raising the version number above.

Continue